Sharon FronkRealtor® · Howard Hanna
LoadingJohnstown, NY 12095 · Fulton County
This 1.35-acre mixed-use property in historic Johnstown comprises four parcels centered on a commercial building dating to 1897. The main structure houses retail space on the ground floor and a two-bedroom apartment above, while additional buildings on the site include a separate house, a third structure, and a barn with original cider mill equipment. The property features creek frontage, a garage, and parking areas, along with outdoor gathering space. Known historically for artisanal ice cream, baked goods, and seasonal events, the site presents multiple income and operational possibilities for a business owner or investor, subject to local approvals.
This unique and well-known property, historically recognized as Wemple & Edick's, has long been cherished for its exceptional homemade ice cream, baked goods, and seasonal craft fairs featuring live music and local vendors. Ideally located just minutes from the Historic, city of Johnstown, NY and the NYS Thruway, this offering presents a rare opportunity to carry on a beloved, nostalgic business with an established reputation and loyal following. The property is being offered as a multi-parcel investment, inclusive of four parcels in total. The main building features the retail space along with a second-floor two-bedroom apartment, providing the option to live onsite, generate rental income, or both. Additional structures on the property include a separate house next door and a third building currently in rough condition, which could be removed to create ample additional parking or reimagined for future use--further expanding the property's versatility and income potential. Another wonderful feature of the property is the historic barn, formerly used as a cider mill, with original equipment still in place, adding character and a true sense of history. The barn is complemented by an inviting outdoor area, perfect for fires, gatherings, and relaxed seating, creating an ideal setting for events or seasonal use. A separate parcel offers ample additional parking along the creek side, creating a beautiful and relaxing setting for customers to enjoy ice cream and gather outdoors. With vision, updates, and care, this property offers exceptional potential for an entrepreneur, investor, or business owner seeking a live/work opportunity. Whether continuing its legacy or creating something new, the possibilities here are truly endless. All possible uses are subject to town approval.
The price signals we can read on this listing today. For a true sense of value against recent Johnstown sales, Sharon will pull the comparable closings and walk you through them.
Google Maps view. Pan, zoom, click a pin to read about a business or place.
Plan a multi-stop route from this address: drop-off the kid, hit the office, head home. Live traffic from Google.
Try a preset
The district this address is assigned to. Ratings and reviews are hosted on GreatSchools.
Assigned districts can change and are not guaranteed. Confirm enrollment boundaries with the district directly before relying on them.
Johnstown is in Fulton County, NY. There are currently 60 active listings here, ranging from $20,000 to $2,900,000. Listings in this address fall under the Johnstown school district. Priced 21% above the Johnstown median of $240,000.
See Sharon's Johnstown community guide
Sharon represents buyers for this property. Your tour, offer, and inquiries go through her, not the listing brokerage.
Howard Hanna Capital Inc · Listed by Christine A Gerber (21107)
Contact: 518-848-7425
MLS #202616386 · Source: Global MLS, Inc.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Sharon Fronk Real Estate is committed to compliance with the Fair Housing Act and provides equal opportunity in housing.
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson · Howard Hanna
Typically responds within 2 hours
Curious whether this home is priced right for the neighborhood?
Ask Sharon for the comps19 facts pulled straight from the MLS listing.
Real numbers from current MLS data. Not a third-party estimate.
Activity across 2 MLS listings of this property.
