Sharon FronkRealtor® · Howard Hanna
LoadingActive
$124,900
189 Main Street
Cherry Valley, NY 13320 · Otsego County
3Baths
2,920Sq Ft
0.66 acresLot Size
1950Year Built
$43Per Sq Ft
Est. P&I $632/moGet pre-qualified
Commercial 15 days on market
MLS# 202624015 Updated 2 weeks ago
Sharon’s Take
This 2,920-square-foot commercial building in Cherry Valley sits on a 0.66-acre corner lot with private parking and municipal water access. The two-story structure, built in 1950, is currently configured as a tavern with a 70-seat dining area, full kitchen, and a classic bar on the main level. The second floor contains two bedrooms and a full bath, offering flexibility for owner occupancy or rental income. Located in Cherry Valley, a village known for its arts programming, historic character, and natural surroundings, the property is within a short drive of Cooperstown's attractions including the Baseball Hall of Fame and Fenimore Opera.
Sharon Fronk · Howard Hanna Capital Region
About this property
Endless opportunity in this 2,920 sqft commercial property, currently a tavern, on a .66-acre corner lot with private parking and municipal water. The two-story building offers versatile space and endless potential. The main level features seating for 70, a stunning classic bar, and fully equipped kitchen. Upstairs offers two bedrooms, full bath--perfect potential owner's residence or rental income. With its vibrant structure and adaptable layout, this building offers limitless potential for many uses. Located in a charming, culturally rich village of Cherry Valley--known for natural beauty, historic heritage, and vibrant arts scene--this property is surrounded by year-round events, shops, and a welcoming community. A short drive to Cooperstown's Dream Park, Opera, and Baseball Hall of Fame.
Is it priced right?
The price signals we can read on this listing today. For a true sense of value against recent Cherry Valley sales, Sharon will pull the comparable closings and walk you through them.
Price per sq ft
$43
Days on market
15
Year built
1950
Curious whether this home is priced right for the neighborhood?
Ask Sharon for the compsProperty details
21 facts pulled straight from the MLS listing.
Overview
Property TypeCommercial
Sub-TypeBusiness
Year Built1950
Days on Market15
StatusActive
MLS Number202624015
ListedAugust 14, 2026
Interior
Bathrooms3
Living Area2,920 sq ft
Interior Features
BasementHigh Speed InternetForced AirPellet StoveOilWoodLaminateParquetCrawl Space
Exterior & Lot
Lot Size0.66 acres
Exterior Features
PrivateGravel
Building & Construction
Construction
Wood Siding
Financial
List Price$124,900
Price per Sq Ft$43
Est. Monthly P&I$632/mo
Location
CountyOtsego
School DistrictCherry Valley-Springfield
Listing Details
Listed ByMatthew Loder of Country Boy Realty
Data SourceSpark Platform / Global MLS
Last UpdatedAug 14, 2026
What's nearby
Google Maps view. Pan, zoom, click a pin to read about a business or place.
Commute Planner
Plan a multi-stop route from this address: drop-off the kid, hit the office, head home. Live traffic from Google.
- Start189 Main Street, Cherry Valley, NY 13320
Try a preset
Schools
The district this address is assigned to. Ratings and reviews are hosted on GreatSchools.
Cherry Valley-Springfield
Assigned school district
Assigned districts can change and are not guaranteed. Confirm enrollment boundaries with the district directly before relying on them.
About Cherry Valley, NY
Cherry Valley is in Otsego County, NY. There are currently 4 active listings here, ranging from $74,000 to $388,000. Listings in this address fall under the Cherry Valley-Springfield school district. Priced 12% above the Cherry Valley median of $111,950.
See Sharon's Cherry Valley community guide
Sharon represents buyers for this property. Your tour, offer, and inquiries go through her, not the listing brokerage.
Country Boy Realty · Listed by Matthew Loder (6543)
Contact: 518-378-1235
MLS #202624015 · Source: Global MLS, Inc.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Sharon Fronk Real Estate is committed to compliance with the Fair Housing Act and provides equal opportunity in housing.