Salem, NY 12865 · Washington County

Fort Salem Theater is a fully operational performing arts venue housed in a circa-1780 building in the heart of Salem, Washington County. The 6,479 square foot space includes a professional proscenium stage, black box theater, dressing rooms, lobby, and administrative areas, along with extensive theater infrastructure and equipment. The property has undergone substantial capital improvements since 2020 and welcomes approximately 30,000 patrons annually through year-round monthly programming. Located within reach of the Capital Region, Southern Vermont, the Berkshires, and Saratoga Springs, this turnkey operation is equipped for theater productions, concerts, lectures, weddings, and community events.
A rare opportunity to own this Pre-Revolutionary building while continuing to shape its future. Fort Salem Theater is one of Washington County's oldest & most recognizable performing arts venues dating back to the late 1700's, offering approximately 6,479 sq ft in the heart of Salem. Lovingly restored and thoughtfully improved since 2020, this fully operational theater blends historic character with modern functionality, creating a truly turnkey opportunity. Inside, guests are welcomed by the warmth and charm that only a historic theater can provide, including authentic audience seating from Broadway's legendary Helen Hayes Theatre, adding a unique connection to New York City's rich theatrical heritage. A professional proscenium stage, a secondary ''black box'' space, backstage dressing rooms, lobby, administrative space, and extensive theater infrastructure are all in place, allowing the next owner to continue operations from day one. The property has benefited from extensive capital improvements and growing attendance, reflecting strong community support and careful stewardship. Included in the sale is a substantial inventory of theater equipment and operational assets, providing exceptional value and minimizing startup costs. Since 2021 the theater has welcomed around 30,000 patrons, with year round, monthly events. While perfectly suited for continued live theater productions, Fort Salem Theater also lends itself to concerts, comedy performances, lectures, educational programming, weddings, private events, community gatherings, nonprofit organizations, houses of worship, and other assembly uses. Conveniently located within easy reach of New York's Capital Region, Southern Vermont, the Berkshires, and Saratoga Springs, Fort Salem Theater represents a rare opportunity to own an established regional destination where history, creativity, and community continue to take center stage. The history of Fort Salem Theater is attached in documents
The price signals we can read on this listing today. For a true sense of value against recent Salem sales, Sharon will pull the comparable closings and walk you through them.
Curious whether this home is priced right for the neighborhood?
Ask Sharon for the comps34 facts pulled straight from the MLS listing.
Tax estimated at the Washington County rate. Insurance and PMI are estimates. Sharon can connect you with a lender for real numbers.
Get pre-approved →Google Maps view. Pan, zoom, click a pin to read about a business or place.
Plan a multi-stop route from this address: drop-off the kid, hit the office, head home. Live traffic from Google.
Try a preset
The district this address is assigned to. Ratings and reviews are hosted on GreatSchools.
Assigned districts can change and are not guaranteed. Confirm enrollment boundaries with the district directly before relying on them.
Salem is in Washington County, NY. There are currently 12 active listings here, ranging from $159,900 to $1,475,000. Listings in this address fall under the Salem school district. Priced 34% above the Salem median of $371,950.
See Sharon's Salem community guideSharon represents buyers for this property. Your tour, offer, and inquiries go through her, not the listing brokerage.
PennyDot Realty · Listed by Penny M Spiezio (21923)
Contact: 518-321-9767
MLS #202622726 · Source: Global MLS, Inc.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Sharon Fronk Real Estate is committed to compliance with the Fair Housing Act and provides equal opportunity in housing.
Real numbers from current MLS data. Not a third-party estimate.
Every change captured by Global MLS since this listing went live.
Public assessment record for the Salem roll · Salem school district · Legitimate Theaters
| Year | Assessed value | Full market value | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $235,000 | $311,258 | +12.6% |
| 2024 | $235,000 | $276,471 | +3.5% |
| 2023 | $235,000 | $267,045 | +13.6% |
| 2022 | $235,000 | $235,000 | +109.7% |
| 2021 | $65,000 | $112,069 |
Assessed and full market values come from the local assessor and lag the market; the tax bill is the assessed value times the town, county and school rates, which the seller’s disclosure will show. STAR and other exemptions are not reflected here.
Outside FEMA-mapped flood hazard areas
This point is not inside any Special Flood Hazard Area or moderate-risk zone on the current FEMA flood map. Flood insurance is optional here and usually inexpensive.
See the official FEMA flood map for this pointSource: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, checked 2026-09-08. Zones are drawn by FEMA and can change; an elevation certificate governs insurance.